One of Bill Parcells' pet peeves was letting a punt hit the ground.  According to former Giant Phil McConkey, this was sacrilege.  "It was against the law, punishable by beheading, if you let that ball hit the ground." said McConkey. 

 Current Giants punt returner Will Blackmon, fortunately for his sake, Bill Parcells is not his coach.  Otherwise, Blackmon would not be wearing blue at all.  This past week, in a critical game against the Dallas Cowboys, Blackmon broke a cardinal Parcells rule.  DO NOT LET PUNTS hit the ground.  Because when a punt returner allows a punt to hit the ground, field position is surrendered.  In the 1986 NFC Championship game, Parcells attributed McConkey's outstanding performance as a difference maker in this game.  Because McConkey caught each punt, the Giants did not lose valuable field position. On the other hand,  the Washington returner did not do a good job at all.  By not catching punts,  Parcells calculated the Redskins conceded 112 yards in field position.  Getting back to Blackmon, he did a poor job fielding punts. In fairness to Blackmon, he could have been thrown off because Dallas' regular punter punts with his right foot.  With Dallas'  punter Mat McBriar sidelined with an injury, rookie punter Chris Jones was inserted into the lineup, and he kicks with his left foot.  Why is this significant?  In the book Football Physics written by Timothy Gay PhD., Bill Belichick wrote the forward.  And this is what he had to share about punting.  If a right-footed punter is kicking, the ball will most likely have a counterclockwise rotation as it approaches. If the punt turns over and descends with the nose down, the ball will break to the left and the returner will have to move quickly in that direction in order to be in position to catch the ball.  If the ball is coming down with the nose up, it will break right.  A wobbly or end-over-end punt will be short.  The opposite would be for a left footed punter.  On Jones' second punt which he boomed for 54 yards,  Blackmon allowed it to hit the ground.  As a result, the ball bounced out of bounds at the Giants 4 yard line.  By not catching this punt, Blackmon put the Giants in bad field position.  However, I am assuming he forgot Jones kicks with his left foot.  Thus, he did not accurately gauge the flight of the ball.  And on Blackmon's muffed punt, the ball was and end-over-end punt.  If this is the case, according to Belichick, the punt will be short.  And Blackmon made grave errors. Besides misjudging the spin on the ball,  he did not follow Parcells' credo on punt returns.

1. Sprint to the ball

2. Do not drift

3. Get Set

4.  Catch it


Thankfully, an alert Greg Jones pounced on the football.  By the Giants recovering the football, they averted a potential disaster.  If Tom Coughlin decides to use Blackmon against the Falcons, let us hope he will play better this week.  

NFL Films guru Greg Cosell reviewed the game tape of the Giants win over the Cowboys.   

Here are some of his takeaways:

Manning continued to show excellent pocket movement in response to pressure, Ability to keep downfield focus and make accurate throws on the move  

Giants did not run the ball with any consistency, They did not win at the point of attack  

C Baas struggled in the run game for the 2^nd consecutive week

Jacobs is not a short yardage runner, He runs too high and loses leverage and power

LT Diehl can be a concern in pass protection when matched one-on-one with quickness on the

Manning outstanding game, especially given Giants inability to run the ball; Great pocket movement and consistent accuracy – He was an elite QB in this game edge

 A key matchup  in this week's wildcard game is the Giants offensive line vs the Falcons defensive line.  The Falcons have a very good run defense.  They finished the season 6th in the league.  Offenses gained an average of 97 yards on the ground.  With Baas continuing to struggle, should Giants head coach Tom Coughlin start Kevin Boothe in his place? 

Eli Manning, clearly, had his best regular season as a pro. Considering the Giants did not have a running game,  Manning was able to guide this team to a 9-7 record and champions of the NFC East.  Although he will most likely not be the league's MVP,  without Manning's outstanding effort all season, the Giants would not have made the post season.  

Other notes:

JPP was named NFC Defensive Player of the Month      

Looks like Spags will not be coming home again.      
  

Even though this NY Giants blog has been more vocal about the adjustments that Perry Fewell needs to make, let's not forget about our friend Kevin Gilbride.  For the last few seasons we have been pounding the table for Gilbride to give Eli more rhythm.  Rhythm is vital for an offense so that it can establish time of possession, give the defense some rest, move the sticks, and get the QB in the flow of the game.  The best way to give a QB rhythm is with small passes to RBs and TEs.  Now obviously there are going to be some long seam passes thrown in to Ballard, but for the most part, we are talking about flares to the RBs and possession routes to the TE.

Below is a table of TE + RB pass catches made in each game, ordered from games with most catches to games with the least.

There are going to be so many variables that factor in to any particular week's breakdown of passing, running, to whom, etc..  So we are not going to make any all-encompassing conclusion and simply say that when you get 9 pass completions to the RBs + TEs that you are going to win the game or other such nonsense.  What we are going to say is that small ball will make your QB better and put him and the offense in a better position to win games.  

The stats in this table may support small ball more than you think... isn't it interesting that the Giants offense was competitive in two of the three losses when they had many TE+RB completions?  isn't it interesting that the Giants offense was slumbering through the first 26 minutes of the Jet game before Victor Cruz's 99 yarder broke open the game on one play?!

One "small ball" play that we have been begging for more of that is simply not practiced enough is the screen.

Another "small ball" play that we love is the INTENTIONAL checkdown flare.  We will keep mentioning it all day... Tom Brady didn't win Super Bowls with only deep passes.  He won it with his checkdowns (think Kevin Faulk) that moved the sticks.  Those plays give you first downs and more opportunities to make other things happen.  Jeff Garcia, a very average QB, made his living with the checkdown.  Drew Brees uses his RBs out of the backfield as well as anyone so that he can continue drives.  

Could these stats be coincident?  Of course.  But look at the attempts.  It looks pretty clear to us that throwing the ball more to your RB on that simple flare can loosen up the offense, give it some success, stretch the defense, and get Eli into the flow of the game.  In a week when the world is abuzz with the exploits of Victor Cruz, let's remember that you can throw more balls to Victor Cruz and let him make more fireworks when your QB is moving the sticks with flares for 7 or 8 yards.  It is not sexy, but it is the 21st Century version of a running game.

We don’t sugar coat things here on UltimateNYG NY Giants blog.  Many of us were drawn to this site due to it’s objectivity and analytical tint. Many of us are critical of players, coaches and staff when it’s due.  We give praise as well when it’s due.  There are instances when we were incorrect or rash in our judgment but we do own up to it.  Bottom line, we want to see NFC East Division winners AND we want trophies shown at the top of this page. 

We are excited about the potential and possible destiny of this team due to the change in approach most noticeable with their Defensive Coordinator, Perry Fewell.  Yes, a DL playing at a high level does make everyone behind them play at a higher level.  But it’s how the personnel has been leveraged recently that Fewell deserves praise.  If we continue to see him rely on more press and man coverage versus what we saw in the majority of his time with the Giants, including in the 3^rd quarter of this past game, then we are given hope. Additionally, the tactical usage of personnel on the defensive line has been key.  When have you ever seen Osi playing on the left side of the line?  How many teams have the luxury of having 2 pro bowl level DEs with the ability to play inside?  Banks adds, “there were times when they went with 4 defensive ends. They had so many configurations that it’s just hard for an offensive line” to match up effectively.  Again, give credit to Fewell for this additional look.  It is simply a different form of pressure.

Banks yesterday gave his seething criticism of Rob Ryan and how he has handled the Cowboy defense in his first season.   Banks goes on to state, “the back end of their defense is where they’ve got their problems.”  But, “I’m just wondering if he’s at the point where he believes that it’s the players and not the system that’s failing and you can’t be so arrogant that you have such a strong belief in your system that you won’t adjust it to the type of players” you have. Because, “in today’s league if you wait on the players to fit your system it’s not happening” versus  “in years past you had guys that your trained for 4 or 5 years in the offseason.  You get them for a certain period time and you’ve got to make certain adjustments” with what they bring to the table.  Banks adds that “it always seems like there is someone off the page” with the Cowboy personnel on the field.  Finally, he ends with a thought we to have have had……”Just wondering if he’s one of those defensive coordinators that just can’t make the adjustments.”  Where have you heard this before? Does the Giants coaching staff’s old school approach explain their lack of adjustment with personnel over these past several seasons? Or are we just overly rash and biased in our assessments?  OR, have they begun to acknowledge that they have had to adjust as they faced elimination these past 2 weeks?

Finally, another element was missing from this team since old gap tooth left after with his ring.  Leadership.  Canty and Kiwi give Rolle credit for ripping into his teammates after the egg they laid versus Washington.  Kiwi admitted that after Rolle’s rant “you saw guys limping out to the practice field, which normally doesn't happen.”
 
“He lit the fire,” Kiwanuka said. “And that's what we needed at the time. You can agree or disagree with him, but normally, what he says is true.”  We heard Rolle being critical of his coaches last season but things have changed with him.  Recently Rolle said “He’s the boss man. We’re his soldiers. We’ve got to get with his program.
 
I was a little stubborn. I was a little … you know … whatever it was. But we’re all on deck. That’s coaches and players included.”  Banks added that the players “heard everyone bashing (their) coach, we love our coach, we want to go to battle for him so everyone who thinks they don’t want to play for him, that’s proof right there.”  Here is another critical element that was missing that gives us hope that perhaps there is a chance for destiny.

The Giants swept the Dallas Cowboys and took the NFC East!  And more importantly, we saw Coughlin's Coordinators use more fundamentally solid gameplans in setting up the win.  We do not want to get TOO excited just yet, but there is something here to be very positive about with respect to the Giants' playoff chances.

Generally we use a format of the Good/Bad/Ugly, but for this game which ends the regular season, we have to separate the discussion into Part 1 for the Dallas win and Part 2 for the State of the NY Giants going into this playoff game vs the Atlanta Falcons.

Part 1

If my wife and I were going to have another child (we're not), I'd give serious consideration to naming it Victor/ia.  The guy is simply all-world.  I cannot imagine what 2012 will be like with Nicks healthy, because Cris Collinsworth and all of us are running out of superlatives for Cruz.  Last week he eclipsed Amani Toomer's single season receiving yard record for the Giants, and this week he shattered the record by racking up another 178 yards on 6 catches.  1536 yards in a single season!  Folks, those are Jerry Rice-type of numbers.  Granted he did this vs a poor secondary, but last week he did it against a good one and his consistency is tremendous.  At this point I have to once again remind myself and everyone else- he has done this with SEVEN STARTS and is still learning in what is effectively his rookie year.  Of course it helps that he has a Pro Bowl QB in Eli Manning, who is also playing at all-world level.  One surpasses the other inside of a single play, where Eli has eyes behind his head (his pocket presence has leaped to otherworldly), escapes sideways and finds Cruz for a great reception to the 9 yard line for the dagger.  Pete raved about him in August of 2010, but even then none of us could have imagined this kind of player.  He has now blown open two games singlehandedly with his YAC.  We noted yesterday how Coughlin remarked that "when a defender takes the wrong angle on Cruz, he makes them pay." Amen to that.  And the Giants collect.  Let's take a moment to finally thank Brandon Stokley for something- the word is that when they brought this guy in, it awoke Cruz to the need to play at a higher level.  And has he ever!

The entire team played well in this effort.  I must give props to Defensive Coordinator Perry Fewell and Offensive Coordinator Kevin Gilbride for doing some of the things we have asked of them.  Those schemes paid off handsomely last night, and we'll talk more about them in Part 2.

Let's rattle off some of the good things to acknowledge how great this win was: Pascoe hurdle, Kiwi's energy everywhere, Boley's flying circus stop on 4th and 1, Ross and Webster in man coverage, Williams and the Safeties vs Witten, Cruz and Manning again because it will never be enough, Manning's hard count offsides successes, Manning's SLIDES after running (hooray!), JPPJPPJPPJPPJPPJPP, the Osi stunt sack, Hynoski hurdle with a total of 4 receptions on top of good blocking, Rolle INT, solid run defense, Fewell's changing pass rush looks (many of which are afforded by a healthy Osi and healthier Tuck).

Part 2

This was a fantastic win.  I admit it- I bitched and moaned about how the Giants were disgraceful and embarrassing vs Washington two weeks ago.  Collinsworth conveniently forgets about that game in his praise of the Giants.  (Yep, nice when it doesn't matter, until it does matter.)  How could a team that could dump a game like this be viable in the playoffs, I asked?  Well, THIS IS HOW> YOUR COORDINATORS START SCHEMING PROPERLY.  What we saw vs Dallas by Gilbride was much more small ball- the dumpoffs/flares to RBs, FBs, TEs that give Eli the rhythm that we have been BEGGING FOR for literally years now.  What we saw vs the Jets and Dallas was much more man coverage and more press coverage too.  So when Collinsworth praises Fewell for turning the corner, that is what it is about.  We tweeted early in the game that giving up 10 yards to Bryant is FINE.  And yes, you can help your pressing corner over the top too.  But when you are playing more press and more man, at least you make the QB earn it.  Gone are the wide open WRs off of free releases and zone sit-downs.  Instead, they'll get their completions from beautifully thrown balls that are threaded perfectly.  THEY'LL GET THEIRS.  But here is the point: WE'LL GET OURS TOO.  We scripted the only way to win it all this season after the NE and SF games... that our offense simply has to outscore the opponent's offense.  The Giants offense can score like mad IF they play enough small ball to keep the defense off the field and let Cruz et al work their wonders.  As long as Fewell attacks with man and press and Gilbride plays small ball the Giants DO have a shot. 

Is this the Gilbride strobe or is it going to become a staple?  Is Fewell going to revert to lots of zone which shreds us to pieces or is he going to abandon that base defense?  IF, BIG IF, but if the light bulb has gone off and they are willing to stick with these schemes, then the Giants can be very VERY competitive throughout the playoffs.  After Washington, I gave the Giants a 0% chance of doing anything in the playoffs.  That was incorrect.  The Giants are still going to have a difficult time with Rodgers or Brees, but at least they can be competitive and let the chips fall where they will.  As long as Gilbride and Fewell are going to gameplan like they did vs Dallas, we have a shot in ANY playoff game.

Before we get too giddy, let's remember who the Giants beat these last 4 games: Dallas and the NY Jets.  Romo was impaired last night.  Let's also remember that Victor Cruz rescued us on a number of occasions- the 3rd and 7 bomb, if incomplete, gives Dallas the ball down 21-14.  Let's remember that Gonzalez and Finley and Graham are much better right now than a hobbled Witten.  MUCH BETTER.  Let's also remember that the Giants got some incredibly fortunate bounces on some horribly ugly plays (Ware fumble on hard count penalty vs Dallas, Jacobs fumble recovered by Eli, muffed Blackmon punt).  The Giants sh*t smells like perfume but if those bounces go the other way everyone is screaming bloody murder.  The point is that winning is the best deodorant and right now, the Giants smell pretty good at 0-0 in the second season.

Summary

SMALL BALL PASSING (10 combined catches to Hynoski, Pascoe, Ware, Bradshaw... and would have been 11 if Jacobs doesn't drop one)

PRESS COVERAGE 75%+ of the time

MAN COVERAGE 85% of the time

MIXED LOOKS FROM DL ON PASS RUSH

HEALTHY TUCK AND OSI for the 5-headed monster

BALLARD BACK??!!

THE POISE OF ELI IN THE PLAYOFFS

We've been very tough on Fewell this season.  The power he holds over the pathway for the Giants is tremendous.  If his adjustments are real and the days of the passive Tampa 2 are behind us, anything is possible.  If you give the opponent a lot of pressure in press, man and (mixed up looks in) pass rush, you are essentially getting a 2007-2008 scheme.  And we know that in 2007 and 2008 anything was possible.  Is this 2007? No it is not.  The Giants still lack the leadership of a Strahan.  But in 2007 the Giants did not have a QB that was half as good as Eli is right now. (In 2011, he has had 10% more attempts and has passed for 4933 yds vs 3336 yds.)  And in 2011, the Giants have a WR that is playing off the charts.  Collinsworth is becoming enamored with the Giants OL.  I am not sold at all- this running attack still smells at times.  But the pass blocking is good and Eli's pocket presence is the stuff that can build 'destiny' runs.  So let's see if there is some January magic.       

Happy New Year, Giants fans.  Please pay particular attention to Coughlin's remarks in #5, #6 and #7. 

Part 1- Coughlin

The NFL Now replayed the interview with Tom Coughlin which aired on Friday.  There were three comments (5, 6, 7) that jumped out, saved for last.

1) Tuck was more like his old self.  Played hard, played a lot of snaps.

2) Optimistic about Osi "being ready to go."

3) When a defender takes the wrong angle on Cruz, he makes them pay.  He was quiet in August.  Took off in Philadelphia.

4) Kevin Boothe has played well in multiple positions.  OL is solidified up front.

5) Coughlin: "We covered very tightly last week."

6) Francesa: How do you respond to the observation that you have strong starts to seasons, but weak finishes?

Coughlin:  "Pick a year and you can say that, pick another year and you can't say that.  That's what I say.  Pick '07, pick '08.  We had a pretty good football team in '08."

7) Coughlin: "You are not going to get to where you want to go without playing against the best teams in the league. Playing the best teams in the league is a good thing."

UltimateNYG here.  Comments made in 5, 6 and 7 are vital to understanding everything we talk about on this NY Giants blog.  Let's talk about each one. 

With regards to #7, we absolutely agree, this is the way to get measured and to learn how to make the necessary adjustments so that when you get to the playoffs you can win a title.  The best thing that happened to the NY Giants in '07 was playing the Patriots in Week 17.  The best thing that happened to the Giants in '08 was playing the Eagles in Week 14.  Both contests provided valuable information for them to use to win each year in the playoffs.  Unfortunately the information was not used in '08, but at least they had the reconnaissance.

Re #5, yes, the Giants did play a lot more press and man coverage on the outside, and it showed.  This is a positive.  Can Fewell AND COUGHLIN see to it that the Giants play more of that tight press and man coverage so that they make opposing offenses EARN it?  Otherwise, with passive off coverage and zone coverage, why bother?!  Hello Tom, it is not too late to make those adjustments and go with more of these schemes.

Re #6, this is EXACTLY what we have been saying on this NY Giants blog for YEARS, and Tom Coughlin proved our point for us!  The only time the Giants did not have these second half collapses was when?  When?  IN '07 and '08!  In '07 and '08, WHEN STEVE SPAGNUOLO WAS THERE!  His words, not ours.  Do you think it was a coincidence?  Now granted, this year the schedule was harder in the second half.  But did anyone ask for Tom to cheese doodle it versus Vince Young in his 1st franchise start for the Eagles?  Did anyone ask for the Giants to get chumped vs Washington's Rex Grossman at home?  Yes, Tom, keep pointing to '07 and '08, keep making our point that you are as good and as bad as the coordinators underneath you.  MAKE THEM BETTER, THAT IS YOUR JOB.  MAKE GILBRIDE BETTER WITH MORE SMALL BALL TO KEEP ELI AND THE OFFENSE IN RHYTHM.  MAKE FEWELL BETTER BY DEMANDING HE USE ROSS AND WEBSTER IN MUCH MORE PRESS AND MAN.

Part 2- Phil Simms on the NFL Now

1) NYG-DAL.  Last time they played, it was there for the Cowboys.  Eli Manning threw the ball away when the Dallas blitz could not be picked up.  Rob Ryan had the defenders in the right position, but the personnel could not execute vs Manning and the Giants WRs.  Dallas secondary is a step down when compared to what they saw w Revis and Cromartie.  Why did the Giants throw at Darrelle Revis?  Stupid.  The Giants could have lost the game with one or two more throws that way.  Romo's condition WILL be an issue, because you need the practice.  His hand/throwing condition will be a factor.  Dallas keeps a defense (and its pass rush) off-balance with screens and draws.  Dallas will need that vs the Giants pass rush.

2) NYJ review.  Sanchez.  He missed a couple of passes, McKnight in particular, although not many.  Sanchez needs two hands on the ball.  Easily corrected.  You suffer with it for about one week and then you have two hands on the ball the rest of your life.  It will stop you from fumbling the ball when you are hit.  The Jets went to a passing game early in the year.  It worked, then it slowed.  Then they went to the run-based offense of the last couple of years.  That worked at times, but it fit them better.    

3) The best team in the AFC?  At the moment, it is the Patriots, who will have the bye and the home field.  The team is built around its offense, they attack in Q4 with a lead.

4) CIN-BAL.  Big game.  BAL falls to a 5 seed from the 2 seed if they lose.  CIN is fighting for a playoff spot.